Bouchard on Nature vs. Nurture (Advanced Lesson)

ESL/EFL Level: C1/C2 (Advanced)
Lesson Topics: behavioral genetics, nature vs. nurture, twins
Skill Focus: Reading, Listening, Speaking, Vocabulary
Approximate Class Time: 1.75 hours
Lesson Plan Download: nature-nurture-twins-advanced-lesson-052025.docx

  • Note to Educators: The roleplay in this lesson involves interviewing a potential sperm donor.
  • The lesson begins with warm-up questions about personality and shared family traits.
  • Next, students read a short 150-word passage containing two discussion questions. The passage summarizes Bouchard et al.'s research on twins from 1990. In short, the research suggests that genetics plays a stronger role than most believe in forming personality traits, intelligence, and interests.
  • The passage is followed by a short, light-hearted YouTube video of two twins who found each other later in life. Surprisingly, their lives are eerily similar, supporting Bouchard's findings.
  • The passage is followed by comprehension questions.
  • Next, students match 11 vocabulary items from both the passage and video to their corresponding definitions.
  • After vocabulary matching, students form discussion questions with the target vocabulary.
  • The lesson has two debate prompts about leadership. This is followed by a ranking activity where students must rank the importance of a variety of factors on personal development (factors include parenting, social media, education, etc)
  • The roleplay scenario involves a married couple who want to have a child with the help of a sperm donor. The couple must interview the donor to infer his intelligence, values, and personality traits. This should be a fun activity for adult students.
  • Next, students review famous quotations related to nature and nurture.
  • Finally, students review vocabulary and collocations before discussing some final discussion questions.

Two twins who became firefighters

ADVANCED (C1/C2) Lesson on Nature vs. Nurture

Warm-up-Questions 

  1. What defines who you are? Is it your personality, physical characteristics, or something else?
  2. How would you describe your personality?
  3. Do you share any personality traits with your family members? How are you similar or different from them?

Membership is required to view this post. Please support EnglishCurrent by becoming a member today. Members, please log in.

This lesson plan was created by Matthew Barton of EnglishCurrent.com (copyright). Site members may photocopy and edit the file for their classes. Permission is not given to rebrand the lesson, redistribute it on another platform, or sell it as part of commercial course curriculum. ChatGPT was used to generate answer keys and some famous quotations. For questions, contact the author.

Comprehension Question Answer Key

  1. ...
  2. Psychological and physiological testing.
  3. The video supports Bouchard’s findings because the twins, raised apart, were still very similar in personality and behavior.
  4. A firefighter noticed Jerry and thought he looked like Mark.
  5. Bald heads, double chins, the way they walk, how they hold beer, sense of humor.
  6. ...

Vocabulary: 1-g, 2-i, 3-k, 4-b, 5-a, 6-j, 7-c, 8-d, 9-h, 10-e, 11-f

Collocations: 1-f, 2-a, 3-b, 4-c, 5-e, 6-d

[1] Sources: Famous Studies in Psychology by Roger R. Hock, https://embryo.asu.edu/pages/sources-human-psychological-differences-minnesota-study-twins-reared-apart-1990-thomas-j

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *