(Background: As a teacher, I have sometimes noticed a slight difference between the use of on the other hand and however. After doing some thinking and research, I believe I can finally explain it.)
The conjunctive adverbs however and on the other hand are used to show contrast (difference), but their meanings are not exactly the same. Let's start with the easiest word, however.
Using 'However'
However can be used between ideas that contrast. In this sense, however is similar to the conjunction but (except that however is an adverb, so it cannot join two clauses).
I want to buy a new laptop. However, I don't have enough money. (positive idea contrasting with a negative one)
I don't like sushi. However, you love it. (negative idea contrasting with a positive one)
Using 'On the Other Hand'
This phrase is used to present two different views or options about an issue. Both views may be valid. In other words, one idea should not refute or cancel the other one out. Here's an example:
Correct: We thought it would be a nice day. However, it rained.
Incorrect: We thought it would be a nice day. On the other hand, it rained.
You should not use On the other hand here because the idea in the second sentence ("it rained") shows that the first idea ("it would be a nice day") was false. This means the first idea is canceled (refuted) by the second idea. Therefore, the sentences do not present two valid views or options.
Correct: I wrote down my answer. However, I later realized that my answer was incorrect.
Incorrect: I wrote down my answer. On the other hand, I later realized that my answer was incorrect.
Again, the second sentence ("I realized my answer was incorrect") shows that the first idea was false, and therefore, not a valid option anymore.
Our hands present actual options.
When something is on one hand or the other hand, that means it is a valid option, e.g: "On the one hand, we could take the car, but on the other hand, we could walk." When you clearly show that one option is not possible, then you would take it off that hand. It makes no sense to consider two options on your hands when one is not possible.
Summary
- Both however and on the other hand are used to show contrast between ideas.
- If one statement refutes the other, you should not use on the other hand.
I admit that the difference between these two phrases is small and only seen in this case. If you have questions, please leave a comment below.
Quiz: However vs. On the other hand
1. I woke up in a panic because I thought it was Monday morning. , it was still the weekend.
Answer & Explanation
However -- you cannot use on the other hand here because the first thought (that it was Monday) is shown to be invalid.
2. Peter wants to become a doctor. , he's not sure that he's smart enough.
Answer & Explanation
However / On the other hand (both are possible) -- the idea that he wants to be a doctor is not canceled out by his uncertainty.
3. We couldn't find our dog anywhere so we were starting to get worried. , our neighbour found him in his yard, thankfully.
Answer & Explanation
However -- you cannot use on the other hand here because the first thought (that our dog was lost) is shown not to be true because your neighbour found him.
-- Written by Matthew Barton of Englishcurrent.com (copyright)
Related Page
Thank you!!
thank you so much
Thank you.
thank you, for your description
thank you so much
This is really useful!!! Thx!!!
That was helpful thank you.
Crisp and clear explanation!!
Tysm
I notice that you use “but” and “on the other hand” together. Is it normal to use them both while they belong to the contrast connectors?
Hello. Yes, though they had similar meanings, ‘but’ is a conjunction, so it is needed to join the clauses. In this case, ‘but, on the other hand, ‘ is similar to ‘…, and furthermore, ”’. Both words have the same meaning, but function different grammatically (‘but, ‘and’ being coordinating conjunctions, while ‘furthermore’ and ‘on the other hand’ are merely adverbs).
She likes walking to school.On the other hand,her father doesn’t have to drive her.
She doesn’t like walking to school . Howerver, her father has no time to drive her today.
Thank you. For helping me in clearing my doubt.
I want to join tomorrow in the fashion show of our class participation in the farewell to BD final year. However, I feel shy infront of crush to go fashion show.
The use of ‘However’ here is correct.
I think that another important point about ‘On the other hand’ might be that that it can only be used to contrast two aspects of one person, place, or thing. For example, when saying ‘The train is fast. On the other hand, it’s really expensive’, you’re saying something positive and something negative about the same method of transport. This is correct English.
It would also be correct to say ‘The train is fast. However, its really expensive.
However, we can’t say ‘The train is fast. On the other hand, the car is more convenient.’ because the contrast is between two different methods of transport. ‘However’ would be needed here because, in addition to showing contrast between two different aspects of the same thing, it can be used to show contrast between two different things, albeit these two things would need to be thematically linked.
I hear what you are saying, but I feel that the example “The train is fast. On the other hand, the car is more convenient.” would be possible for someone considering two possible transportation options. Each hand holds one option, each of which the speaker is deliberating over.
Hello, my dear help me with this question. I can’t be sure about the answer.
It is true, this is time consuming ————–, it brings in a lot of money. You know how much they pay him? A million birr!
A, however B, but in fact C, eventhough then D, but on the other hand
You haven’t used proper punctuation so it is hard to use that as guide. I would say A, B, and D are all possible.